Challenges Being a Pacifist

I am a pacifist. Some people in this community can’t handle this, and want to see my posts removed, my objections silenced, and/or me constantly feel ashamed about myself.

While I want to say I fundamentally do not care about what moderators think, the fact is that I do, deeply, and every time one of my posts is removed for objecting to my favorite software being used in weapons programs it kinda emotionally destroys me and makes me want to engage with this community less and less. This is why I have stopped even considering contributing to the Nix community.

Here is what is happening within Nix community spaces. I state a moral objection to military use of the tools we build, and the post is removed. Meanwhile a thread asking everyone to stop objecting to defense work stays open, and people are encouraged to post in it. The same request, to just disengage and not make anyone feel bad, is welcome from one side and censored from the other.

I do not care if someone does not want to interact with me because of my views, but I care deeply when moderators remove what I say and treat me as the problem. I’m making this post to communicate that this is extremely unwelcome behavior, towards me and anyone who holds a conviction the moderators don’t personally share, and to please stop. Apply the rules evenly. Don’t remove my objections while protecting the opposite position. Don’t try to make me feel bad. I didn’t ask.

Short edit because slow mode: thank you to everyone who has sent me kind and encouraging words. I am not morally conflicted about what I believe, and I don’t mind briefly explaining my position when I can post in this thread again)

16 Likes

As was communicated to you, you, and anyone else reading this, are free to voice moral objections to the defense industry, provided you do so in ways that are not personal attacks directed at other community members, per our Code of Conduct. As a pacifist, I’m sure you’ll find that not attacking people is a principle you can get behind.

We strive to protect all of our community members from anyone who would attack them, full stop.

15 Likes

As per my last email, that has not been my experience here whatsoever but thanks for your (curt) response. From my perspective and seeing how many anti-defense industry posts have been censored, there is extra effort to protect those that pay the bills despite the VERY negative effects that their involvement has had on NixOS/Nix.

The original thread now reads like a one-sided “trials and tribulations of having no moral integrity” while those that don’t bathe their pacifist stance in word salad are banned, censored, and removed. I don’t dare post anything there for fear of being banned, though the thread carries on like a Nazi bar might with the absence of pushback.

The other part I take exception with is you hiding my post in meta. That was, IMO, a cowardly move that defanged my post; an action that can hide behind plausible deniability for you but for me, it was a clear case of censorship. I put that post in uncategorized purposely as a response to the thread I was censored and threatened by mods about then you moved it here to hide it from the much needed community discussion that would (SHOULD) ensue.

I’m beyond disappointed with this community and especially the moderation team who have all but confirmed their bias with clear, observably biased actions where they carry water for anyone that wants to pile on and lament the fact that others have strong moral compasses.

6 Likes

Our policy is that public criticism of moderation actions goes in the Moderation category here, because historically that sort of post tends to draw a lot of bad-faith commenters and sucks a lot of the oxygen out of the forum if unregulated.

You’re welcome to whatever opinion of us you want. I assure you that we’re also getting DMs from people who think we’re far too supportive of the anti-military faction. Our Code of Conduct prohibits personal attacks and harassment, the statement of which is the entirety of the ‘threat’ you’ve received from us. Communicate respectfully or take a break; if you think that is an unreasonable constraint on your freedom of speech, this may not be the right place for you.

6 Likes

While I respect that you have strong personal views, I think there might be a misunderstanding about where the pushback in this community is coming from. When you encounter friction here, it generally isn’t because people “can’t handle” your pacifism or take issue with your specific worldview. People come here using and contributing to code without telling you what to use it for. So they simply don’t like it if you’re telling them what to use it for. And there is a huge difference between “I am an X and don’t like Y” (people would accept that and then continue with their own business) and “You should not use this code for Z” (people would get defensive because you are overreaching).

NixOS is a sprawling global community made up of people with very very diverse backgrounds, beliefs, and values. A core value of FOSS is its neutrality. It exists to be used by anyone. Attempting to dictate or restrict how the software should be used based on personal philosophy, especially in a project that has been operating independently for a long time, often comes across as overreaching.

The reality is that people aren’t focused on validating or debating each other’s personal worldviews. Respect here is earned simply by contributing to the project and interacting politely with peers. If we stick to those basics of collaborating on the code and treating one another with basic courtesy, then everyone is welcome, and we can all work together productively.

5 Likes

Let the record state that @tfc doesn’t exactly speak for all of us here.

It’s true and important that we are a diverse community. It’s not true that we’ve enshrined ‘neutrality’ as a community value, and that isn’t how we moderate. It’s true that some community members would prefer that it is, and those community members may voice that preference. Moderation will not.

There is a difference between politeness norms and civility norms. Politeness optimizes for smooth interactions. One politely compliments the hosts at their party, even if one is having a bad time. A polite disagreement is one that doesn’t touch on sensitive subjects at all. If one happens to become upset in polite company, the polite thing to do is to minimize one’s emotional response. Civility, by contrast, optimizes for respect and the building of long-term relationships. Civility allows for honesty, even on difficult matters, when that honesty is voiced in a way that allows for reconciliation and forward progress. Civility doesn’t require one to repress important issues, because long-term relationships between people will not thrive under such conditions. It is possible to be both civil and polite, but civility is one of our community values, and politeness is not.

Neither this topic nor the topic that inspired it are polite. That’s okay. They are acceptably civil (this one perhaps wouldn’t be if its subject were anything other than the moderation team, for just how satirical it is, but I’d rather get skewered myself than have that energy brought to bear on another community member). Both topics have garnered uncivil responses; these have been moderated. We do close the occasional topic when it is clear that a civil conversation is no longer at all likely. But don’t confuse that with expecting politeness.

11 Likes

Let the record state that @tfc doesn’t exactly speak for all of us here.

Thanks for the breakdown, i just learned the difference between polite and civil from your explanation, and it makes complete sense. Regarding the rest of your post, it reads a bit like you’re distancing yourself from my original point, but I think we’re on the same page.

1 Like

Obviously, everyone is free to do what they want.

But I’m not interested in:

  • engaging in a dialogue with
  • collaborating with
  • normalizing
  • tacitly approving of
  • building technologies that will be used by

war criminals

this account will be suspended by request as soon as you have time to read my response. (As I write this, that’s about 16 hours from now because my posts have been artificially been put into slow mode because the kids here don’t want to offend their genocidal, are criminal sponsors)

I’m out. I can read the room. I see now that I was a fool for believing that I could defiantly stand up and speak up for those that aren’t ok with what has happened to the NixOS community because I have no corporate job to lose. But I’ve received FAR more pushback than support for giving a shit about money.

Ps. I’ve received multiple DM’s trying to get me to engage in a dialogue with actual war criminals which, to me, qualifies as a gentle, legal, passing form of harassment. GTFO of my personal messages with your pleas to find a common ground with people that are completely fine with murder for money that also want me to feel conflicted about drawing a hard line about that murder for money. I desperately need a job but somehow I can find other ways to support my family that don’t include aforementioned murder for money. I must be an idiot, not being fine with murder for money. After all. That’s the only job left in software engineering.. /s

1 Like