After the events of last week, two RFCs have been locked and restricted to “collaborators”.
I have a few points to note about this.
First off, who is/isn’t a collaborator? If I understand GitHub’s docs about this, it’s people with write access to a repo/org.
As someone who has participated in this community for a few years now, but with no commit bit, I find it unfair to be unable to participate. I also don’t think that technical skills equate to social/ethical/empathy skills, so the tools seems very blunt and to hit the wrong target.
Therefore, I would like to ask the current moderators to clarify what their strategy is regarding the locked RFCs:
- Do they plan on unlocking them?
- Can we have some transparency as to why the locking was necessary?
- Assuming the banning of an individual user is justified and well directed, shouldn’t that be enough to then let the conversation proceed? Were we really at a point where there was no conversation possible, among the broader community? If that’s so, that wasn’t my impression
And lastly, I wold like to note the irony of a Request for Comments being closed to comments from the wider community