It’s linked on Community | Nix & NixOS and some people prefer realtime chat over forum style. But I do think it’s a shame to put help info behind a closed door.
An important detail you left out is that this Discrod is listed as an UNOFFICIAL platform. That fact in of itself seems to be a clear enough warning why not to use it for communications.
Overall as of recent times there has been a lot of migration in open-source projects to Discord, not just in the NixOS community. Why do I feel this should stop?
First, we need to see this for what it really is.
Convenience? Well that is relative. To me, a non-discord user, it presents nothing but inconveniences. Sure, I’ll give some that Discord is convenient for real-time communication, but that is a weak basis for it’s use. IRC is convenient. Forums are convenient. Email is convenient.
The major problem is that Discord is proprietary, and inherently lacks the archival capabilities and searchability that I see as essential for maintaining a transparent and accessible record of project development, collective problem solving, and the list goes on and on. I see this shift from traditional internet platforms like, IRC, BBS, mailing lists, forums, etc; to corporate, centralized ephemeral chat environments as an existential threat to the survival of the free and open Internet as we know it. The pattern creates a fragmented knowledge base, where crucial decisions, bug reports, and development discussions are easily lost or obscured in vast message histories that are not owned or maintained by the public. The total proprietary nature of Discord means that critical project data is locked into a platform that could change its policies, terms, or even shut down, jeopardizing the continuity of these discussions. Using Discord goes against the open, accessible nature of open-source projects.
I can not endorse relying on Discord for project discourse in any way. I only see it as representing an anti-pattern, compromising the sustainability, transparency, and collaborative spirit essential to the success and health of NixOS.
Okay, that’s my soap-box. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
Buhbye.